Llandaff Fields Tree Masacre

Treeline at the junction of Penhill and Cardiff Roads before felling
Treeline at the same location after fellng

By Les Mills, Bute Parks Alliance

What is it about Cardiff Council Planning Department? Cycling through Llandaf Fields yesterday morning I saw some workmen working near some quite beautiful Lime and Sycamore trees bordering the edge of the park. I assumed they were simply pruning some of the trees as they often do.The tree line bordering the park stretching from Penhill Road all the way over to Western Avenue are mostly mature Lime and Sycamore and they are quite spectacularly handsome as are most of the trees lining the edges of the parks – they contain and define the limits of the Park acting as reassuring green barriers and giving parks users a sense of removal from the largely anodyne surroundings  bordering the Parks. It is the main reason why people retreat to the parks to relax, unwind and enjoy themselves in a largely rural, less polluted and more tranquil green environment to enjoy a multitude of pursuits.

 Three hours later, returning the same way, I looked over to where the workmen had been and what I saw stunned me. What had once been a solid green wall of mature trees was now violated by two huge treeless gaps in the wall of trees revealing mounds of building debris, torn vegetation and earth moving machines in the building site behind. Shocked, I approached some workmen and asked them why they had removed the trees and they simply said, “Because we were working under Council orders” and they named the official in charge. When I said why were those particular trees removed- were they rotten? They said,  “No they weren’t rotten, we don’t know why but it was probably to give the future owners of the apartment blocks a clear view of the parks” If this is true then we are astounded at the ramifications of this. It would mean that the council had prioritised the future comfort and enjoyment of a small number of private owners of the apartments over the enjoyment and pleasure of the huge numbers of the public at large in one of the most beautiful parks in the UK. It is as if the Council members or Officials who make these rash decisions have never heard of the aesthetics of landscaping, bio diversity or even  Climate Change and have no respect for the opinions and views of their electorate.

 I walked over to the Penhill traffic lights to where the entrance to the building site was and I was astounded by the sheer amount of excavations being undertaken  in order, I presume, to construct the foundations for the apartment blocks and lay garden areas. Looking down into the gap I could see through the large gaping holes into the open grass field of Llandaf fields whereas previously the view was blocked by the sycamore trees. So it seemed to confirm the view of the workmen I’d spoken to earlier i.e. that some future owners of the apartments would be able to have an unrestricted view of the parks because of the removal of those four mature trees. Could it be that this would be a strong selling point aimed at potential purchasers of the apartments? If this is the case then it is a scandal that decimating beautiful mature trees on public land would have occurred for the benefit of private developer’s profit. Bute Park Alliance will write to local councillors to demand an explanation for why the trees were removed in such a blatantly ruthless  and unnecessary way. We feel that this senseless destruction of mature trees in Llandaf Fields runs contrary to the Councils’ stated views that they are committed to a policy of tree preservation throughout the city and especially in the Parks.

7 thoughts on “Llandaff Fields Tree Masacre

  1. Hi Les.

    I had a quick look through the planning docs, here: https://planningonline.cardiff.gov.uk/online-applications/applicationDetails.do?keyVal=_CARDIFF_DCAPR_123072&activeTab=summary

    It seems as though permission was given for removing a number of mature trees within the development site, and also a group of mature sycamores in Llandaff Fields (judged to be ‘low quality’). There were no objections from Parks or the Tree Officer, in part because the developer is due to plant some ‘replacement’ trees within parks boundary. Think this is probably emblematic of a wider problem, where replacing mature trees with saplings is deemed to be a sufficient offset in planning terms.

    It is made clear that the felling was only permitted to take place outside of nesting season (October to March 1st).


  2. Utterly disgraceful to desecrate such a beautiful Park in this manner. I am sure that the next thing will be “there were no birds nesting in the trees”. How on earth can Cardiff Council who work for the benefit of all Residents defend themselves in this?

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s